Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Harry Neutel's avatar

I had an interesting conversation with an indigenous business owner in northern Saskatchewanian yesterday about all this recent interest from the defense industry of partnering with indigenous groups, and he was fairly dismissive, and said you had to be a chief to get any of that money. He went on to discuss how much of the benefits of arrangements with norhtern mining companies seemed to go to the businesses owned by the chief and his family members.

Now, this was pretty clearly gossip, but it does raise an issue that has troubled me for a while. How do we ensure that Canada's attempts to make up for past injustice do not perpetuate new injustice? From the outside looking in, it's really hard to tell who is a responsible steward of resources intended to assist many people. I've read many stories of well intentioned people getting in over the head, and squandering resources out of ignorance, or an unwillingness to ask for assistance. Or waste and corruption going unnoticed and unaddressed because there are just not enough people qualified to supervise the resources. And of people being influenced by misinformation campaigns to go against their own best interests. And many reserves have genuine problems with gangs and drugs, and the addictions that surround them. There can be a real conflict between trying to get the resources disbursed to those in need, and trying to ensure that you aren't just feeding a loved one's drug habit.

I don't know the answer. I am too far outside the community to provide any real assistance, other than trying not to ignore it. I eagerly read any story of indigenous business success, I love to see an underdog victory, but I try to avoid rose tinted glasses as well, and I don't know how to balance those two impulses.

I'd love to hear from anyone who is from the indigenous community, or who has worked with some of the indigenous groups that are getting active in the defense industry, how effective is this at strengthening the communities that are basis of these groups?

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?