
Happy Monday!
It's another Let’s Talk, and this week we're running back some of our usual updates. Roshel, CDC, VLS, River-class. After a few weeks of diversity and chaos, we're back to some smooooth sailing and our usual drumbeats.
I won't keep you all here for too long, we got some fun questions this week, though admittedly, I can already feel people are anxious about things like the Batch-II Rivers! I'm sorry y'all, but we still got a long way to go yet.
As always, you can find the link to ask questions for next weeks Q&A over here on Slido!
Q1. Are there any other small arms recapitalizations coming? HMGs are much needed. Mortars, rockets, GMGs, etc.
There are several that fall into this category, but not as many as you probably want to hear. There have been talks of both a C6 and C9 modernization over the last year, but it is very small and as far as I know it’s not in a place we can really discuss anything.
There are a surprising amount of projects that exist that way for a long time before suddenly showing up, so it doesn’t mean they ain’t gonna happen, but they’re at most conversations right now, very early stages. There sadly isn’t much to say other than Army leadership is at least thinking about it.
Mortars move over to IFM. If you’re talking about stuff like bringing back the famous 60mm, then no. There ain’t any plans I know of, despite everyone over the age of 35 seemingly praying for them to come back. I also like the 60mm mortars, so I feel the pain.
You mention rockets, so I wanna make note, and the specifics people don’t come flooding with definitions, that we are receiving new M72 (which will soon be produced here!) as well as the new M4 variants of the Carl G.
Both are already under contract and delivering. I have had a chance to play around with the M4 myself and see it up close. They are absolutely perfect and I will accept no other opinions on them.
Q2. So, if Roshel is chosen for LUV, are they only offering their LUV vehicle? Are they also offering the Senators too? Like the Senator Pickup?
Well, that’s up to the Army to decide, and that might feel like a weird response, but it’s sorta indicative of the state of LUV. See, when it comes to LUV, no one quite knows what they actually want.
The debate over what kinda vehicle Phase II needs is still an active conversation despite an award coming quick. There are a lot of folks who see the Senator as out of scope for what Phase II set out to acquire, too big, too heavy. That also comes back to a wider issue in the CAF about philosophies on vehicles, the role of light and medium platforms, and this weird desire to maintain some form of traditionalism.
I digress, because that is a whole conversation. I would know, I regularly talk to my friends about this for hours at a time and it always just ends on a sad whimper. The point is, the Roshel LUV is more a hedge than one would admit.
It exists as an alternative to the Senator because there are many not comfortable with the Senator as is, and would prefer a bulky pickup over a proper PMV. Now, Roshel has done a really cool job on the LUV, and they see potential outside the CAF, but its existence here is primarily driven by this innate inability to come to terms on what platforms are viable.
The Senator sadly falls into a category many ain’t ready to accept, despite everything telling them that this is the direction everyone is moving.
Q3. Follow-up to last week’s new base question: which current bases would be primed for significant expansion: Suffield, Winnipeg, Shilo, North Bay? Anything else?
The funny thing is, all the bases you listed are looking at massive expansions over the coming years, just not in all the same ways. I think the distinction should be noted in that regard, as expansion comes in many forms: physical, through mandate, in people, etc.
Suffield is the most notable one, as Canada’s largest training area. There are a lot of plans to better utilize Suffield over the coming years. That includes the continuation of BATUS, yes, but there are a lot of conversations on both allied and private partners using Suffield for their own purposes.
Poland and Korea, as an example, have shown interest in having a dedicated presence in Suffield, for example. Alberta has been pushing to open up the base to private industry for things like testing long-range communication systems, testing autonomous systems, and hypersonic testing.
A lot of that is being pushed by the province itself, which sees Suffield as a strategic asset for helping support Alberta’s own Defence ecosystem. Greater provincial influence on the use of available land and existing facilities is becoming more of a conversation since the release of the DIS, and there is an openness from the government to allow these developments to happen.
Shilo is also undergoing a massive modernization and expansion of its existing infrastructure. There is the new Land Vehicle Crew Training System facility, the new transition centre being built.
It will get a significant expansion with infrastructure for IFM. That includes new secure storage facilities, headquarters and office space, and new garages and workshops. Shilo is also set for a major modernization of their munition storage facilities through ACE-P. That also includes Trenton, Dundurn, Angus, and Bedford.
There are talks of North Bay hosting the future GlobalEye fleet, and some other ideas I sadly am not allowed to discuss publicly. Winnipeg is getting upgrades needed to support FAcT. There are also things like the Future Combined Aerospace Operations Centre Capability project.
That project will modernize the Canadian Combined Air Operations Centre with a new, advanced, defended airpower C2 system that will utilize modern cloud computing and machine learning systems to aid in quicker, more decisive decision-making as part of our NORAD commitments.
Honestly, you would be hard-pressed to find a base not primed for major expansion! There is so much infrastructure planned or being built that it is honestly amazing. DCC is awarding so many contracts they need to throw out multi-page PDFs just so folks like me can keep track!
We’re committing tens of billions through things like NNBI, DCFI, and projects like CPSP to base expansion. I think the amount of it is near ungodly when you really dive into things. That’s before you pull out stuff like RAGNAR, which makes the whole conversation REALLY out there.
Q4. Do you think Roshel’s chances at getting the LUV contract have plummeted after the Brampton controversy?
No. I have yet to see someone really mad at Roshel on the Federal side. If they are, they ain’t showing it. Roshel came in as one of several suitors. They won out. Some might be upset with how it went down, but there were several interested parties involved.
It isn’t lost that the Defence Industrial Base also needs to support itself, and that this is the kind of expansion the Feds have been championing since the DIS was released. Few companies fit the government’s view of a Canadian success in the defence space better than Roshel.
Q5. You mentioned up to 3000 LUV, this is coming closer to what I think we need, still not enough, where did you hear this? Background? New Project?
That is the closer number to what is being looked at with the current LUV numbers plus some proposed expansions that are out there. The moment LUV drops, the moment a contract is signed, there are several groups who are gonna immediately rush in to expand those numbers.
New variants (Ambulance, Strike, CUAS), ARes Modernization, and a much larger 1st Div than planned are all gonna probably push that number BEYOND 3000 in the future. People forget how limited the LUV scope really is in the modern context, and how versatile a platform like the Senator is. It fits a lot of roles, and a lot of gaps we have really freaking easily, and there are more than a handful of folks salivating at the idea.
Sadly I can’t discuss things in detail, not yet at least.
Q6. Besides the option for the P-8s, if we ever needed more MPA aircraft, would you say the PAL P4 would be the likely candidate in terms of complementing the P-8?
I think it depends on what you want and need. The P4 is a very interesting aircraft, I think it could have a future role in our defence ecosystem as we eventually look to replace the existing Dash fleet.
There is value in maintaining manned aircraft, especially modern aircraft with the built-in infrastructure and capability to not only act as a sensor but command platform to things like autonomous systems.
Modern systems are continuously getting more efficient, smaller, and accessible. Same as technology progresses and manned-unmanned teaming becomes more commonplace. There is value in having humans inside that loop.
For the RCAF though, which is already pretty at capacity (again, one of the constraints to more P-8 is people), the more likely avenue is expanding on our autonomous fleet to better supplement existing manned assets like the P-8.
That includes things like Guardian, yes, but it’ll also include things like Air-Launched Effectors, future collaborative aircraft, maybe even things like aerostat in the future. All of which don’t replace manned aircraft but do fill critical gaps and help extend their capabilities.
So there are opportunities in places, and less so in the place people expect.
Q7. With the acquisition of the S-100 (CU-179 Peregrine), where does that place the CU-176 Gargoyle?
Gargoyle is long dead. It never lived up to the expectations set, was expensive, and never advanced into a true capability. The difference is that Peregrine does exist, will hopefully deliver capability, and will be a native RCN asset under their control.
Q8. In your opinion, how many VLS should RCD Batch 2 have? They should be able to perform AAW including anti-ballistic, land attack and possibly ASuW (Tyrfing?)
Funny thing is, even the Navy is not set on a true end-to-end anti-ballistic capability as people imagine. A lot of actual interception concepts are based off networking land-based systems being fed by something like a River-class. That is much more frequently discussed when looking at Continental defence, which is the River’s primary anti-ballistic role.
Anywho, I stand 32 is my minimum as always. That is sorta, kinda the base standard for most combatants in that range. Would I like to see more? Sure. Would I complain? No. The River-class was never designed or intended to be an AAW Destroyer, nor should we be trying to force it to be one.
If we want one, we should just look for a dedicated one and not force ourselves through hell and high water to make the River-class something it isn’t.
Q9. Any updates on additional logistics trucks? Also, LFE, the initial buy was for 90. Any word on the rest?
No update. All the existing projects for more trucks are very early stages, Identification to be specific. They are still a fair ways off from being at a place where we can reasonably discuss them. As for LFE? The Phase II RFI has closed. RFP comes next year with a contract award planned for 2028.
There are some talks of accelerating that, mind you. Never say never with DAME and LUV both going to limited tender.
Q10. “Back to the drawing board” for CDC sounds like strip to bare bones. Is the Pocket Halifax still desired and they are talking more about specifics now?
I think there is a recognition that CDC needed to come back down a bit, not downgrade, but the pace of growth in the project was becoming... unsustainable and perhaps a bit detrimental to the Navy. There are some things I think they recognize as not being worth it, or at least confliction that needs a winner.
Ice class, for example, is an area most are keen to cut, as the discussion and focus has limited designs and isn’t worth the trade-off. Range is also an issue. Getting 7000nm out of a combatant like this is difficult. It pushed for a larger platform that might not be worth it.
That’s the other thing. While the size limit isn’t being enforced, some concepts were starting to push beyond 120m, which presented some issues. The growth was becoming unsustainable. It was allowed to go unchecked, but now the Navy has to present their case to the Feds, to the Treasury Board, and that can quickly knock someone back to reality.
Is a bigger, fancier ship worth the risk? Is it worth it if we don’t see the numbers we need? A few bespoke hulls is nice, but is that what Canada needs? The Treasury Board is already looking to control costs across the board. A super expensive Ultrafax doesn’t exist in isolation. It requires some sacrifice at the altar, so to speak, to come into reality, and even then it doesn’t promise you what you need.
So the Navy has gone back to better solidify their requirements and figure out exactly what they need. That isn’t bad, it’s actually a great thing. Scope creep is a knife at your throat that you gamble with.
Q11. Do you think there is any interest in us getting the Meteor missile for F-35 or Gripen?
There’s interest in Meteor. The RCAF is currently looking at options beyond the AIM-120 as part of our future Long-Range Air-to-Air missile project. Meteor is one of the contenders to fulfill that requirement, though we will have to wait a bit to see how well it fits against something like the AIM-260.
The project is still early stages, so we don’t have a great sense of requirements, what capabilities are wanted, etc. I do think Meteor, if it can figure out its 35 integration in a timely manner to what it has been, can fit well.
Q12. Any updates on the RCN FASST-V program?
An RFI should be coming soon. It is absolutely one of the Navy’s major priorities right now, and I know they’re working hard to get something out there before the end of the year if possible.
Q13. Is RCN considering increased VLS on the RCD Batch 2 vessels, given allies and other nations are installing/planning increased VLS magazines?
They’ve been considering it since the start lol. They’re never not considering it. The Navy wants more VLS on the River. They have been very open about wanting more. They elected not to on the first batch to avoid potential redesign or delays in the design ahead of construction.
The Halifax are in rough shape. We need hulls yesterday. It doesn’t matter if they’re perfect, if they’re what the Navy exactly wants, because a ship in the water is better than no ship anywhere.
So, we accept some loss there in hopes that buys us some time for future batches to be more experimental and take risks.
Q14. Any update on RCD timelines? Is the target still ‘32 for first in class? My understanding is we are less than a month behind AUS and theirs is shooting for ‘32.
Early 2030s, and I will leave it there because trying to lock down a year right now is a random guess. Construction on Fraser is still early, going good from what I hear, the hull is taking some semblance of shape, but still early, still first of class, and we are still learning how to build the Type 26.
The Brits don’t build the same as us, they don’t have the same methodologies and system in place, so there is a learning curve. So I am a bit hesitant to throw out an exact number or date. Around 2032 is a good middle ground, maybe it comes 2031 if things go really freaking awesome. I think it’s safe to stick to early 2030s for now.
Q15. What’s PSPC, ISED and TBS’s role in projects? Do they slow things down or is that just a myth?
So obviously there is some shifting being undertaken, but the general roles stay the same for the most part: PSPC runs the competition and signs the contract, ISED makes sure Canadian industry gets work out of it, and Treasury Board approves the spending.
The DIA takes on the major projects, negotiating and managing those contracts itself, and now has authority for the ITB Policy, still working with ISED, mind you. Under Bill C-40 it would become a Crown corporation with its own minister, more power to approve contracts on its own, and a $1 billion fund to lend to and invest in defence companies.
That’s the basic breakdown of roles, with the caveat C-40 leaves things open in terms of division of authority, who gets what, how the Treasury Board plays into things, etc. All of that is yet to be set in policy.
As for the second half of that question? It’s complex, real complex... the truth is that the blame for delays is not as simple as any organization. Some are more guilty than others. The Treasury Board is notoriously risk-averse, overly burdensome, and is notoriously slow. Approvals can stretch over a year in some cases for things that should be measured in weeks.
Part of that is a lack of resources, both in terms of the attention defence files receive but also in organizational capacity. The TB folks also have issues here, and it’s a topic that’s been raised here a lot the last few weeks, that the DND is providing what the TB deems weak and incomplete submissions for major projects that force deeper reviews and delay the approval process. There is also a lot of concern that the DND isn’t doing proper costing and providing faulty numbers.
That, though, gets into a big back-and-forth of everyone blaming each other that is honestly more a headache than it’s worth. Add to the fact projects need to go through multiple approval processes across several departments, each one invites potential delays.
ISED and PSPC definitely ain’t innocent, but their role in delays tends to be specific to certain projects and in many cases they ain’t always the crux of the issue like some say. The DND, mind you, also isn’t innocent in how they allocate resources and how often projects can shift, case in point CDC.
The DIA is supposed to help fix this by bringing more of the process and policy under one banner versus running through several organizations. It is also working in tandem with other policies, such as PSPC’s Risk-Based Approach to Contract Approval for Defence Procurement and getting the Treasury Board involved in approvals far earlier in the process so they can be more involved and engaged early on.
There’s also lots of outside factors that can delay projects. Federal policy is one, legal action, even ATIP requests can oftentimes delay projects if they’re captured in their scope.
Delays are a complex issue. Frequent delays are a foundational issue that doesn’t disappear easily or without radical change. There are ways that the system is trying to fix things, and results are showing. The hope is that once the DIA is fully operating that a lot of these constraints can be further tackled.
Q16. For future River-class batches, are they sticking with 3 at a time or would there be a larger order when they’ve worked out any bugs?
The hope is to lock down on bigger batches if the government is open to it. There is a desire to do two more batches of six to hit the total fifteen.
That provides some certainty to Industry more than three at a time, allows for greater investment into the program, and helps better build the supply chain by allowing for some better commitment from the Feds to supporting the River-class. It also locks down costs and timelines a lot better than smaller batches of three at a time, which is important for a major, expensive program.
It also locks down the River-class numbers far more strategically than small batches at a time that are easier to cancel or suspend in the future if a future government tried to target the program.
But how big the next batch is depends on the Federal government’s approval.
Q17. Do you know if the pushback for CDC requirements is from the Navy or government? If not, theories?
Everywhere? There’s always pushback on things, especially for a major project that is going to be expensive and have different views on what’s needed. Everyone has a mandate, and everyone is going to try and execute on it.
Q18. Do you see the LAV 6 Mk.2 being procured? Either as a full platform or as a turret upgrade, or an upgrade like III to 6.
I mean, the Mk.2 aligns well to what ACV-W wants, but I am hesitant to say exactly. The Mk.2 is a concept. It was an attempt to show what could be possible. No production variant was going to just look like a Mk.2.
More likely, we see incremental modernization as ACV-W transitions hopefully into a continuous procurement model.
Q19. Will the Type 212CD be modified to meet the requirements of Canada? Or will they pursue as much commonality as possible?
There are some things that will need to be looked at in the Canadian context. Upward-facing sonar is one area that is often brought up in the Canadian context.
There is also likely to be a domestication between all of us on batteries (not battery systems, mind you). Whether companies like Gastops support the global fleet or just Canadian I also don’t know.
There is also likely to be Canadization over time, but the core of the submarines, engines, AIP, CMS, sensors, munitions are all to be aligned to the three fleets. While there won’t be 100% commonality, there will be enough broad commonality to essentially be common.
So they will essentially be common designs to each other.
Q20. Why wasn’t GDLS-C able to participate in the LUV competition with their version of the GDELS Eagle?
They were. They openly participated and it was determined Eagle didn’t fit the requirements set out. Others like Hawkei also got eliminated despite a lot of hype. Why were they eliminated? I can’t say.
You can find the link to next weeks slido here!













